Hi guys, the past while I was trying to find good comparisons between these two models of dd's. Has anyone tested both ? I understand that the software for these aren't complete yet but is there any clear winner here ? thanks.
Podium DD's VS Simucube 2's
- Thread starter Darren Byrne
- Start date
TedBrosby-
Premium
To be fair, even on a supported wheel, Forza isn't exactly known for its quality FFB. You have to set the bar low, to "it has FFB so I know what's happening to the car" and that's it. The centering force and dead zone, the details are all basically as basic as it gets. So even if you're not happy with how EmuWheel feels/ForzaWheel, I don't think people should expect a supported wheel to feel much better.
That's fine, but you can't expect other people to feel the same way and the fact is, if someone wants to play Gran Turismo with a wheel, and also drive iRacing for the "serious" online racing, Podium F1 has an advantage over Simucube and I wish people wouldn't just dismiss preferences and circumstances that make that true.
Just because Podium is a better wheelbase for consoles doesn't all of a sudden crown Fanatec as the better direct drive wheelbase.
One thing I can't understand is how everyone who compares these two wheelbases, treats it like an all or nothing comparison. For them, either the Simucube is better at 100% of the details or it's not better at all, and I don't agree with that.
If you only drive the "pure" PC sims like AMS, iRacing, RaceRoom, rFactor 2, ACC etc, and you don't mind how expensive the wireless wheels are, then yeah the SC2 is better than the DD1, but as soon as "I want to play on Xbox or PS5 as well" comes up, you should just admit the Fanatec is better for that person.
Upvote
0
Des Pearce
Premium
Sorry Ted I wrote a long reply but don't want to get into an argument. I thought I had admitted exactly that and also that I may well have made a different choice if my current situation was different?
Last edited:
Upvote
0
I think people who are thinking of moving away from the SC2 system into the fanatec realm are a little on edge in certain simracing spaces. I think a lot of this is just a misunderstanding. I empathize with Ted because I know firsthand that trying to discuss the thought of "regressing" to a DD1 or DD2 can trigger some fervent tribalism.
Reading over both of your responses it seems like there might not be as much (or any, really) animosity there at all. I think the simracing community at-large right now can be a little tribal and toxic, so operating in these discussions can feel a bit weird. I mean, I had someone DM me telling me to kill myself on discord for talking about choosing the DD1 over the SC2.
I honestly don't think Ted was trying to direct the discussion to you specifically.
Reading over both of your responses it seems like there might not be as much (or any, really) animosity there at all. I think the simracing community at-large right now can be a little tribal and toxic, so operating in these discussions can feel a bit weird. I mean, I had someone DM me telling me to kill myself on discord for talking about choosing the DD1 over the SC2.
I honestly don't think Ted was trying to direct the discussion to you specifically.
Upvote
0
TedBrosby-
Premium
@TheNatural has it right. Sorry for coming off as defensive, but I feel like whenever anyone tries to make the case for why they are considering Fanatec, an angry horde descends upon them to dismiss their preferences as minor or trivial. You don't need to race on console, real sims are on PC, it's plastic junk, etc.
I personally feel like I can get great advice here, but only if I follow the herd. As soon as you want to try something different, you have to be on guard. This is less "Podium DDs vs Simucube 2s" and more "Everyone vs Fanatec owners".
I personally feel like I can get great advice here, but only if I follow the herd. As soon as you want to try something different, you have to be on guard. This is less "Podium DDs vs Simucube 2s" and more "Everyone vs Fanatec owners".
Upvote
0
Des Pearce
Premium
I've only had one dealing with Fanatec, it wasn't great but got sorted, eventually, in a way I was ok with. Nothing against the kit, many of the ideas are great (DD enclosure, wireless wheels, loadcell upgrades) and at a different time I may well have bought a DD1 with Formula rim and BMW round rim.
Apologies for any offence given, I hope they do the job for you.
Apologies for any offence given, I hope they do the job for you.
Upvote
0
D
Deleted member 197115
-
Deleted member 197115
Emuwheel creator made the mod for supported wheels as it does improve FFB quite significantly. After all the tuning I was pretty impressed with FM7 on OSW wheel.
I believe they already have telemetry based version. May be FM8 will have native support. A man can dream, right?
I believe they already have telemetry based version. May be FM8 will have native support. A man can dream, right?
Upvote
0
stigs2cousin
Premium
Would Emuwheel be able to give a useable FFB to DirtRally2 ?
I´ve tried with the SC2 and after tinkering for a bit deleted DR2 because the FFB was between "not there" and apalling.
MFG Carsten
I´ve tried with the SC2 and after tinkering for a bit deleted DR2 because the FFB was between "not there" and apalling.
MFG Carsten
Upvote
0
Mr Latte
Premium
So to ask again for confirmation
If a Fantec owner had the Playstation & Xbox compatible hardware
Will it work with:
A) Other types of USB pedals?
B) Other types of USB pedals but with some form of USB - Fanatec Adapter?
I simply want to know if owners are locked into using Fanatecs pedals.
If a Fantec owner had the Playstation & Xbox compatible hardware
Will it work with:
A) Other types of USB pedals?
B) Other types of USB pedals but with some form of USB - Fanatec Adapter?
I simply want to know if owners are locked into using Fanatecs pedals.
Last edited:
Upvote
0
On PC you can use whatever you want, but on console your controller can only have one USB input, so your shifter/pedals/base all need to be connected to something that then connects to the console.
Upvote
0
Mr Latte
Premium
We used to be able to get pedal adapters that allowed Logitech G27/29 pedals to work with Fanatec RJ45 hub on their wheels. Are you certain something like this is still not possible?
I dont think this is technically as difficult as the wheel base support.
It's doing the opposite of what Fanatec's own adapter does with shifters/handbrake.
Instead of the shifter/handbrake (RJ45) being the input
We want the USB device to be the input and the (RJ45) connection to be the output.
This would then allow USB pedals to connect into the wheel hub to use on console.
Last edited:
Upvote
0
As far as I know it will work on PS5 with Podium Racing Wheel F1.
For DD1/2 you will need an additional controller.
To be completely sure ask in GTP DriveHub thread.
Upvote
0
So someone from GD replied saying such filter is reserved for Ultimate, so it will never be added to Pro and Sport?
That would be weird, because it’s neither advanced nor complicated filter to implement. And if they have it for Ultimate it wouldn’t be much additional effort to add it to other versions. Ultimate already differentiates itself from cheaper versions by incorporating quite different hardware and people will buy it because of that.
Such filter with 25Nm wheel is not only reasonable, but would give some advantage over other DD wheels.
At least it’s great that you found a workaround for iRacing.
Last edited:
Upvote
0
TedBrosby-
Premium
Unfortunately, you can either use a single USB device or DriveHub.
Good news is DriveHub is pretty native. You end up being able to use Heusinkveld pedals and instead of the Podium F1, you can get the normal DD1 which is cheaper.
They do need to adjust it because apparently it's difficult with PS5 (need a PS4 controller or something, maybe that's changed).
I'm also a bit conflicted. SC2 vs Fanatec DD is a hard choice, but I can sacrifice the SC2 advantages since I know at least it's a decent DD (on par with SC1 apparently but very spiky torque). With pedals however, I've had my Sprint pedals for about 5 months now and honestly I don't know if I can see myself sacrificing them.
What I'm actually considering, is taking a Fanatec CSL Elite LC electronics set (the sensors/potentiometers, load cell) and installing them into my HE Sprint pedals as a Frankenstein.
Upvote
0
Mr Latte
Premium
Appreciate the response of some others and yourself on this.
For me, this is one of the bigger dilemmas on what DD platform I go with.
The idea with the pedals also crossed my mind but could be a bit of work.
I have concerns that with PS5 if Sony comes up with some way to prevent unofficial methods from working and a title like GT7 to perhaps only support "GT Licensed" controllers and prevent joypad emulation from working. I guess we won't know till it is released but would feel safer with the supported wheelbase. I just hope Fanatec have a new "GT" licensed wheel package coming.
Would be keen to see someone do a mod on pedals or somebody come up with a converter cable for pedals from USB-RJ45.
I did find THIS which is designed to extend USB devices up to 150ft
Not what we need, but it does have the required connections. HERE is the USB female - RJ45 on its own and also THIS as an adapter plug. Might be worth trying before any pedal conversions.
Last edited:
Upvote
0
If console compatibility is concern then sticking to mainstream brands obviously makes the most sense.
Sony and MS didn't make closed systems to then spend the time and resources to make them work with proprietary peripherals.
At no point do I expect my SC1, HPP pedals, Wheel and VR to be supported by either console and I didn't build my setup with that in mind either.
Sony and MS didn't make closed systems to then spend the time and resources to make them work with proprietary peripherals.
At no point do I expect my SC1, HPP pedals, Wheel and VR to be supported by either console and I didn't build my setup with that in mind either.
Last edited:
Upvote
0
Mr Latte
Premium
Fanatec is a mainstream brand with a supported wheelbase if the user wants that.
The query is if other USB pedals can be used via an adapter or converter of some type when using the officially supported wheel with consoles.
I have never seen anyone in any review video tackle this matter or people having tried what is being asked.
The point of this is to simply avoid
A) Being locked into using V3 pedals with Fanatec wheelbase
B) Buying BOTH a PC Pedal set and a V3 pedal set
C) Having to swap out pedals continually
1x Official PS5 Wheelbase 1x Higher-end USB Pedals is the desired goal.
If it's not possible then it goes to swaying my purchase decision.
The query is if other USB pedals can be used via an adapter or converter of some type when using the officially supported wheel with consoles.
I have never seen anyone in any review video tackle this matter or people having tried what is being asked.
The point of this is to simply avoid
A) Being locked into using V3 pedals with Fanatec wheelbase
B) Buying BOTH a PC Pedal set and a V3 pedal set
C) Having to swap out pedals continually
1x Official PS5 Wheelbase 1x Higher-end USB Pedals is the desired goal.
If it's not possible then it goes to swaying my purchase decision.
Last edited:
Upvote
0
