Not really fair to act like that when teams have not given him great machinery. He got a pole in a Williams that had a technical issue that forced him to retire, was on track for a podium when a Caterham screwed him. He and Perez have been the kings of the midfield (now with Sainz), which is not what I would call "lackluster."
also people keep pointing out how perez got podiums when hulk didnt.
but where did it lead perez? its not like perez has suddenly been offered a top seat at any team. he only had a single year in a top team, and that top team turned out to not even be a top team in 2013.
lets be real here, even if hulk scored a podium or two like perez, would he have gotten a top seat regardless? argubly not. red bull is reversed to red bull program drivers which hulk was never part of. merc had rosberg and hamilton, two drivers which merc was completely happy with and no matter what hulk did, would have never gotten that merc seat. hulk was in contention for the 2013/14 ferrari seat (great season for him btw, outscored perez by nearly 40 points despite perez podium, but i guess that counts for nothing) but ferrari decided for massa in 2013 due to him having a decent performance when it counted and decided for alonso in 2014. so hulk signed a long term contract with force india.
that contract was up by the end of the 2016 season where ferrari was happy with their seb/kimi pairing, lewis was happy in mercedes and red bull still only takes red bull drivers.
so suddenly rosberg retires and a top spot is open. and hülkenberg was actually one of the drivers mercedes tried to contact. the day after rosberg retired, mercedes contacted renault and tried to see if they could buy out hulks contract since hulk had already signed a 3 year contract with renault. renault said no and that was the end of that story. of course hulk wasnt the only driver who was contacted by merc, it is worth mentioning what could have been.
my point is, opportunities at a top team are very very rare and there are plenty of drivers who deserved the shot but never got it due to simply unlucky timing. you all love to mention how perez got the podiums that hulk didnt (not gonna go in-depth about that one but hulk had plenty of qualities that perez didnt) but perez just like hulk has never gotten a shot at a top team (besides mclaren 2013), so its not like all those podiums have gotten him anywhere.
hulk is the modern day heidfeld, a very fast and a very consistent driver who should have had a shot but never has gotten one. it is an extremely lazy argument to say "hes had his chances at a podium but never got it" and therefore assume that hes not worthy of a top seat. we are talking about very few races, 2,3 or 4 races where he couldve gotten a podium. so youre gonna judge his entire career that consists of 177 races based on 2-4 races? what about the 173 other ones? do they not count? to me the average race counts far more than a rare standout race. you would be stupid to consider somebody like maldonado or stroll better than hulk just because they have a single podium.
and it is worth mentioning he did win le mans in one of the most competitive le mans races. 8 hybrid lmp1 cars competed in that race and his team came out on top.
i really hope he returns to f1 in 2021, hes still better than most of the f1 drivers.