I'm not gonna debate with you,I said my piece.All i did is asked the man if he could do it.It's not my problem if you can't take some critique.First you said of course he can do it better and then you said he can't do it better.
That was not critique, critique would involve you actually giving points for improvement and identifying flaws, not just saying "this isn't that good". You have not provided any legitimate reasons for disliking w1n1x's work, and honestly you'd be pretty hard pressed to find any, because it's a pretty damn decent skin