Here are my thoughts and a list of cosmetic issues I've noticed in the game with this mod. Most issues are minor. I'm new to F1 in all respects, and have no comment on car performance, driver performance, or real liveries.
Info:
Game version: Current stable release (Steam); Mod version: 2.3 (Mega); OS: Windows 10 64-bit; Extraction tool: WinRAR 64-bit version 5.91; Other mods: None. Most images are from the starting grid at a sunny Career race in Australia.
Issues:
Renault:
In the Rivals window, Ricciardo's picture shows Verstappen. Ricciardo's correct picture or model is used in all other contexts I've seen, including rival selection (Verstappen uses correct images and models).
Williams:
Vertical ABK logo is upside down on both sides (halo and others OK).
I understand the left side Rokit and Orlen mirroring issue is known and can't be fixed.
Alfa Romeo:
Left side Sauber Engineering logo is mirrored.
In the Rivals window, Raikonnen's picture is too wide (he lost his elbows!).
Player Career or Time Trial car only: Wheel has displaced knobs (AI and player controlled Raikonnen and Giovinazzi are OK).
Red and faded-red bits all over mirrors, mini-wings, vertical pieces, and generally all over the outside of the cockpit. More so on the left side of the car. There are also white and red spots on the tip of the nose.
https://i.imgur.com/92ANRc1.png
Ferrari:
Left side IIR logo ahead of cockpit is mirrored.
https://i.imgur.com/5eB1Emz.png
Player Career or Time Trial car only: Missing knobs (AI and player controlled Vettel and Leclerc are OK).
https://i.imgur.com/92LC7fE.png
Driver hats (in datacenter, podium) have red bits on them.
https://i.imgur.com/OW5inRZ.png
McLaren:
Low-resolution textures (both sides). See upper mid-rear and air scoop, bottom sponsor lists, large front side Vype logos.
The orange background of the same Vype logos is also the wrong shade, and both the logo and background quality varies between bad and awful depending on camera distance (may be using distant textures?).
The orange background of the
@McLarenF1 and #TeamBahrain decal on the outside of the cockpit is discoloured, with the same wrong shade and similar behaviour compared to the front side Vype piece (both sides; may be intended).
https://i.imgur.com/kcWMl6k.png
Vype logos on left side of cockpit are mirrored.
https://i.imgur.com/ED0Dypd.png
Weird green piece below rear light (may be intended).
https://i.imgur.com/yZQR2VQ.png
Toro Rosso:
Honda logo by cockpit is partly cut off.
https://i.imgur.com/pqOiMuq.png and another angle:
https://i.imgur.com/FS22lef.png
Action For Road Safety logo on front wing is mid-low resolution and has small blue-black spots forward of it.
https://i.imgur.com/Gkq6LM0.png
Mercedes:
AMG logo mirrored on left side.
https://i.imgur.com/r5taha3.png
Haas:
Low-resolution textures on fin (both sides) and rear wing blue.def logos (both sides; may be using distant textures?). Left rear wing blue.def logo is also upside-down.
https://i.imgur.com/GvMSAIR.png
Racing Point:
Left rear wing JCB logo is mirrored. Left mid-rear SportPesa Racing logo has only the word Racing mirrored. Left mid-rear Claro logo is mirrored. Left rear Acronis logo is distorted.
Five odd spots are on the sides of the car, four white and one black:
white square on left side near Acronis logo;
small black intrusion into white line through left rear Univa logo;
small white vertical scratch on left side midway between BWT and Univa logos;
small white curved triangle just rear of the E logos beneath air scoop (both sides).
The car's white, pink, and blue pattern gets jumbled up around the cockpit (both sides), mainly with large pink inclusions in the blue area and in the white strips.
https://i.imgur.com/RwYtMCp.png
The SportPesa logos near the TV camera pod are truncated to "SportPe" and their "e"s are half cut off (both sides).
https://i.imgur.com/VcERUdi.png
Five more white spots are around the end of the nose.
https://i.imgur.com/Fb0UkUF.png
Player Career or Time Trial car only: Wheel has displaced knobs (AI or player controlled Perez and Stroll are OK).
https://i.imgur.com/HTJeiLq.png
Red Bull:
Action For Road Safety logo on front wing is mid-low resolution and has a sliver taken off the top.
There is a small grey spot near the end of the nose.
https://i.imgur.com/opGlDUO.png
Conclusion:
Visually, this mod is very nice flavour update and graphical enhancement (and again, in this post I only have opinions about in-game cosmetic issues). That may have been a pretty hefty list of issues, but for each issue a dozen little and big things are done very well. I could probably be here for days listing them. However, I'm going to single out a few good things:
1. The issues I cite with both Red Bull cars are incredibly trivial. In particular, I almost missed any issue with the Aston Martin.
2. I couldn't find any issue at all with the Renault car. Wow.
3. Mercedes. One tiny issue. Again, a super job.
4. I disproportionately appreciate the updated driver names on the cars.
5. To me, the driver pictures and the uniform changes are dramatic improvements and enhance my enjoyment of the game's visual aspect.
6. I love the newer liveries (except Racing Point and McLaren, due to listed issues). They really draw out the beauty of the cars.
Thank you for an excellent mod.