As some have already said in this thread, this did not give me a nice feel with my T300. The steering goes all light and then when I increase gain to compensate, I experience major clipping. So nice idea, but not for me.
I think this is normal behavior for the T300. It's like when you tick "Linear" in iRacing. Wheels like the T300 are relatively weak and AC's standard force feedback certainly boosts low forces to allow us to feel them. This is why the standard AC ffb is not considered linear i.e. boosted lower forces and reduced strong forces. So when we tell AC to send the forces as they are in reality through a LUT file, the T300 is not strong enough to make us feel the lower forces. Hence the feeling of lightness most of the time. When we increase gain in this situation, we get clipping on strong forces because they are sent as strong as they were sent with standard ffb.
It is disappointing because I'm faster with the LUT file than with the standard ffb but I still find the feel too light even with the T300 ffb control panel cranked at 100%.
I have attempted something to counteract this. Maybe someone can tell me if I'm just hitting the same problem without knowing it... Here's what I did:
My theory was that I can boost the wheel ffb strength through the LUT file. To make that so, I modified the LUT file by increasing all values sent to the wheel (on the right side) by a factor. So far I try 1.5 (50% stronger) and 3 (150% stronger - too strong...). Here's an example of 1.5:
Generated LUT:
0|0
0.02|0.088
0.04|0.097
...
0.96|0.804
0.98|0.936
1|1
Modified LUT:
0|0
0.02|0.132
0.04|0.146
...
0.96|1.206
0.98|1.404
1|1.5
This delivers stronger ffb across the board and there is no more reported clipping than with the original LUT. Actually, FFBClip reports exactly the same numbers as with the original LUT. My initial driving impressions seem to show that I retain, with this, the capability of being faster than with standard ffb. My questions are:
- Am I now getting clipping without knowing it because the game evaluates clipping before processing the LUT file?
(I don't know how I can find out)
- Do I distort the linearity since I'm changing the output values to the wheel (even if they are a constant factor)?
(My initial testing seems to show that it's still linear but this is not proof)
What do you think?